Comments: Is The GOP Stepping Back From The Political Abyss On Immigration?

One question;
How many times does Frist have to commit political suicide before they bury his sorry carcus.

Posted by Ron In Portland at March 28, 2006 08:10 PM

wrt to "Here's a related question: if Specter beats Frist on this issue, what happens when Specter confronts a weakened Frist on the NSA issue later?," methinks we need not wonder about such a matter, since the odds of Specter confronting anyone on the NSA are somewhere between slim and none.

Posted by howard at March 28, 2006 08:14 PM

How did the Democrats manage to get Big Media to present this immigration thing as a strictly Republican concern? What a huge sleight of hand. Jesus! Like the Democrats' position on this is irrelevant? Like they aren't going to have to take a position on this, too?

Hmmm. What is black America saying about the unfettered influx of cheap Mexican labor? Has anyone asked Ray Nagin his thoughts on the matter?

Posted by Toby Petzold at March 28, 2006 09:03 PM

sure, betcha Bushie will sign it....and then append a signing statement that renders the whole exercise meaningless.

Posted by susan at March 28, 2006 09:07 PM

Imagine 500,000 demonstrators lined up with Mexican flags, on the Mexican side of the border simultaneously walking into the US. At what point would that become an invasion?

NSA answer: Frist will fist Specter's sphincter.

Posted by TIKI AL at March 29, 2006 12:00 AM

How did the Democrats manage to get Big Media to present this immigration thing as a strictly Republican concern?

I think it has to do with the radical Tancredo bill and the extreme Cornyn/Kyl's proposal's not being viable. Some cooler heads had to prevail. Millions of hispanics marching will do that.
Radical repukes aren't happy of course. Moderate repukes are happy because they are able to maintain their caste system status over the Hispanics.

What is black America saying about the unfettered influx of cheap Mexican labor?

I've not seen too many crews of white, black or white teenage contruction workers, landscapers, crop pickers, janitors or hotel maids in 5 years, some workforce areas for 10 years.

Posted by bbtb at March 29, 2006 01:28 AM

I'm a Democrat, but I depart from the Democratic postition to just let any Tomas, Ricardo and HArry waltz across the border. In fact, I think we should take the most extreme measures possible to kick the illegals out of the country.

I live in NC and we are absolutely overrun with illegal Hispanic immigrants. They are overwhelming social services, the schools and the hospitals. MAny are paid in cash under the table. It is a huge problem.

I think every illegal immigrant should be rounded up and thrown out of the country. Any employer caught with illegals on the payroll should be fined 100K for each illegal immigrant in their employ. We should build guardposts every 0.5 kilometers along the border, man them with a team of four people and two M-60 machine guns 24/7/365, and shoot on sight anyone caught crossing the border.

There was a point in time where the US could be welcoming of anyone wanting to come to the country. Those days are gone. Until we can take care of our own citizens, we shouldn't be letting the US become greater Mexico.

Posted by WyldPirate at March 29, 2006 05:30 AM

One question;
How many times does Frist have to commit political suicide before they bury his sorry carcus.
Posted by Ron In Portland at March 28, 2006 08:10 PM

*****

He's got nine lives...

...like those cats he tortured.

Posted by God Of War at March 29, 2006 05:38 AM

How did the Democrats manage to get Big Media to present this immigration thing as a strictly Republican concern? What a huge sleight of hand. Jesus! Like the Democrats' position on this is irrelevant? Like they aren't going to have to take a position on this, too?

Hmmm. What is black America saying about the unfettered influx of cheap Mexican labor? Has anyone asked Ray Nagin his thoughts on the matter?
Posted by Toby Petzold at March 28, 2006 09:03 PM

*****

First off, your party is in power, and reminds us of that fact daily by shutting down dissent, so there's the answer to strawman question #1.

WTF does Ray Nagin have to do with this? Geez, Toby, it looks like you might be the kind of guy who says "nigger" without irony. How Republican of you.

Posted by God Of War at March 29, 2006 05:41 AM

It's the Employers, stupid... Criminalize the hiring of undocumented workers, the jobs dry up, problem solved. Duh!

Posted by Ken in MN at March 29, 2006 06:12 AM

My question is: why the hell did Kennedy see the need to help the repugnican promotion of McCain as the new compassionate conservative ? Is there reason to believe Kennedy thinks the votes aren't there ? And that a M-K association in any form will be seen as a stain to the repugnican extremists (ok, both terms aren't necessary) ?


Posted by self at March 29, 2006 06:21 AM

Some serious questions since I'm ignorant on immigration issues:

-if we need all these illegal immigrants to keep our country running (we are told Americans don't want these jobs), why don't we just let more people in legally?

-What is "wrong" with Mexico that it is a poor country that everyone wants to leave? It's a democracy, they have tourism, do they have any exports? Do they have a decent education system there? Why isn't it more "developed" than it is? Is CAFTA supposed to help with developing Latin America? Do you think it will help?

-What are the biggest problems with illegal immigration? Overwhelming social services? In what ways? I'm not trying to be dense--I really just don't know anything about it.

-What would happen if we sent all the illegals back tomorrow (has anyone seen the movie "A Day without a Mexican"?) What would happen if instead, we made them all legal tomorrow?

-What would motivate anyone to sign up for guest worker status where they have to leave in 6 years, when they can just stay illegally under the radar forever?

Posted by CG at March 29, 2006 06:44 AM

I usually agree with you but you are wrong on thr illegal immigration problem. You need to find out what people really think. Watch Lou Dobbs.

Posted by JohnT at March 29, 2006 06:49 AM

This is a nutty idea. We outsource jobs out of the country and we insource unemployed foreigners to undercut American workers in the construction, hotel, and restaurant industries. Yes thats right. I guarantee you once the immigrants get legal status, they will stop picking fruit and look for better paying jobs. Then we are back to more illegals sneaking across the border.

Posted by Bill the psychometrician at March 29, 2006 06:50 AM

Yes, the illegal immigration problem is real. However, the current debate in Congress is a total smokescreen. In a nutshell, Bush allowed the immigration to please his big business masters. To get lower labor costs in manufacturing, you move the plant to somewhere that has cheap labor. To lower the labor costs in the service industry, you allow undocumented workers to flood over the border. In both cases the workers are exploited, have terrible working conditions and have no recourse when they are abused. To make the 11 million undocumented workers now in the US instant felons is insanity, as is somehow shipping all of them back to their home countries. If we can't effectively evacuate a few hundred thousand people from New Orleans, how do you expect to send 11 million illegals out of the country? Make the employers that hire these people the felons, make the fines huge, put business owners in prison for violating the laws that already are on the books, and watch the problem evaporate virtually overnight.

Posted by Ken in MN at March 29, 2006 07:30 AM

Bill the psychometrician, No, your wrong but their children might!

Posted by bbtb at March 29, 2006 07:56 AM

It's the Employers, stupid... Criminalize the hiring of undocumented workers, the jobs dry up, problem solved. Duh!

It already is criminalized, it's just not enforced. Cuts to federal programs, like INS, mean that things don't get investigated. And businesses will continue to pay undocumented workers under the table to avoid scrutiny.

Having worked in the restaurant business for many years, I can also tell you that it is damn hard to determine the fake "green cards" from the real ones. Someone out there makes great fakes. There needs to be a way for employers to easily and quickly verify immigrant status before you can start arresting or fining employers.

Posted by ann at March 29, 2006 08:32 AM
[Editor: ignore=on]

Stv, dn’t hv cl s t ny hddn GP gnd hr, thr thn n ntntnl pll lwrng bhvr, bt th fct s tht llgl/ndcmntd lns ds nt ql ‘mmgrtn.’ Whl y nd r trtd lk crmnls t th lcl rprt, ndcmntd flks r crssng th brdr nd f whch cld b n th mply f th bg-bd-trrrst. Ths w nt th mckry f ‘scrty’ t th rprts thr thn th pssblty f prtctng crprt prprty, (plns).

Frthr, t lst 20% f llgls thr hv prr cnvctns r r nn-pprhndd drg smgglrs. ls, ndcmntd flks mpct wht s lft f r nstttns, spclly dctn nd lw nfrcmnt. Sth mrcn prnts, lk r ntrnchd dt prnts, r nbl t cp wth r ‘nythng gs’ mntlty whn t cms t prmssv chld-rrng. Ths, thr kds qckly lrn hw t ct t sng thr lf-strgglng sklls t ntmdt r sft/wk kds. Ths typcl hmn bllyng trt s nw ntrnchd n r lrdy gngstr dlzd pp cltr whch dds ddtnl wght t psychlgclly ntrp th kds nt th prsn cltr, r t lst glrfyng th dcy f vlnc.

ls, whn w hr th crp bt llgls r ‘vlbl t d th wrk mrcns dn’t wnt t,’ w mst dsmss ths s nnsns. r crp lrds bld fctrs n thrd wrld cntrs t py lwr wgs; r crp pnks llw ‘llgls’ nt r cntry t py lwr wgs. s lwys, ndrnth th prft/pwr strctr f ths pnks s th mmrlty qtnt. Frthr, th mr mprl w bcm, th mr w llw bth lgl nd llgl mmgrtn, nd th mr scl cnfsn bcms ntrnchd n th mnds f r rhd vtrs s ‘wy f lf.’ Cnfsn nd chs crts cvr fr r crp lrds t cntn n thr trck f th mmrlty f wrld cnqst, lngsd thr Nw Wrld rdr f rstcrcy.

Fnlly, f r gvrnmnt srvnts f r Crp Lrds sy tht w hv ‘11 mlln’ llgls, thn th nmbr s clsr t 50 mlln. f w cn pss lws t stp r ft nd sft btthd smkrs frm smkng rnd chldrn, thn w shld b bl t pss lws t nfrc rl Brdr Ptrl, (ths ndrpd nd nsng hrs nd mch mlgnd Fdrl Lw nfrcmnt ffcrs. sbmt tht w gt ll th grl FB, D, S Mrshls, nd DD fft t d mmdt brdr ptrl srvllnc. Cnvrsly, sbmt tht w pt r Brdr Ptrl gnts n th crrnt FB stts, thn w wll s sm rl wrk gt dn; fr nstnc, sm RC nvstgtns nttd pn r Crprt Mbstrs. nd gt rd f tht psr FB ‘lb.’ Bnch f gnrnt pnks n th pyrll. h, yh, f th FB s t d Brdr Ptrl, bttr bld thm n srl Cncrt Brrr…bhnd thm. Thy‘d b rnnng frm rl wrk.)

[Editor: ignore=off]

Posted by scout at March 29, 2006 10:43 AM

To all on the Left:

I have a question, why do you guys refer to Hispanics as people of color?
We can be of any color! Also why do you lump us in with Blacks and Gays? We have our own issues and want to be treated seperately. So please stop using the term minorities, it's offensive.

To WyldPirate:
Typical of racist leftist. Try rounding up illegals and see all Hispanics in this country unite to defend our brothers with guns! I see you're from North Carolina, well we're not Jim Crowe era blacks and will just let you Klansmen attack us. We'll fight back with Guns and cause a civil war.
Was your grandfather a Klansman? It take it as yes. Come here to South Florida with your racist junk and you'll be hunged!

Posted by Conquistador at March 29, 2006 04:14 PM
[Editor: ignore=on]

Cnqstdr, th nly ‘mnrty’ tht knw prsnlly bt r ths tht fr Gd. nd, lldng t dmns, d y knw hw mny ppl th rl ‘cnqstdrs’ mrdrd, nslvd, rpd, pllgd, nd brtlly trtrd, n thr prst f Nw Wrld wlth? nd dn’t frgt ll th ld Wrld dsss ths mltry dvntrrs lnchd pn th nprtctd ndgns ppltn.

Nw, f y’r flng srry fr th ntv mrcns, wll thy wrn’t th ncst grp f mrdrs fls, thr. Th Tltc, ztcs nd Myns, nd th ncs dwn lwr dd lt f dth dlng n th nm f vrs sprt dmns nd th typcl pltcl/rlgs wrs. Th Nrth mrcn ndn grps, whl lss rgnzd, ls wr nt th ‘nbl svgs’ dpctd by th lks f s-clld phlsphrs sch s th Frnch kk, Rss.

Jdgng by yr cmmnt f ‘ppl f clr,’ y mst b bt 40-45 yrs ld, r s. Dd y cm vr n tht Mrlt grp tht Fdl lt t f Cb drng th rly 80’s, r s? f s, tht ws tgh.

Fnlly, vry chld brn n th S s ctzn, lthgh thnk lttl Bsh’s cbl hs trd t d n nd-rn n ths spct f th Cnstttn s wll. Thr s n wy tht nyn s gng t lt llgl prnts f S ctzns b xprtd. blv w hv ngh rl mthrs n th cntry t pt stp t sch n d.

Whn g t Gtml, hv dcmnttn; Brzl, th sm. Y s my pnt. Dcmnttn f ppl crssng brdrs s rsnbl by ntrntnl stndrds. nc n whl vn n nsn prsn lk lttl Bsh cn hv vry smll mmnt f tmprry snty; bt sspct tht ths mmgrtn dl my hv ltrr mtvs tht my b ncvrd n th ftr. Hy, wld y gys pls tk Flrd?! Thnks!

[Editor: ignore=off]

Posted by scout at March 29, 2006 05:43 PM

Conquistador,

Bring it on motherfucker. You're way outnumbered and a lot of folks are getting tired of your sorry wetback asses. Moreover, your own goddamned countries should take care of their own people.


Nothing racist about it. We can't take care of our own problems and this isn't an empty country anymore.

Illegal immigrants are depressing wages and causing havoc. I wouldn't mind seeing every goddamned one of 'em rounded up and loaded in cargo nets and dropprd at altitude from a helicopter on Vicente Fox's hacienda.

Posted by WyldPirate at March 29, 2006 06:08 PM

To the Klansman WyldPirate,

No, you're outnumbered Cracker. There are 22 Latin american countries with a population 400 Million. If a civil war between Hispanic and Whites broke out we would take South Florida, The Southwest and Southern California easily. At that point the armies of Cuba, Mexico, Venezuela, Colmbia and other Spanish nations would join in. At that point you would be crushed becuase nobody would help you. Russia and China would intervene on the Hispanic side to bring America down. Your Children and Grandchildren would then be our vassals. I'm not wetback Mexican but a Spaniard. In case your ignorant trailer park inbred White trash half a brain didn't know Spain controlled large parts of Europe in the 1500's. So my Ancestors were your Ancestors masters. I love this country and have a cousin fighting in Iraq, but just fair warning to your Racist ilk we will not let happen to us what happen to the Jews in Germany or the Blacks during the Jim Crowe era. We'll drown this country Sea to bloody sea. This is just a warning!

Posted by Conquistador at March 29, 2006 06:32 PM

To Scout,

I'm 30 of Spaniard Origin. I have no quarrel with you. You seem a knowledgable person. I was just alluding that I still see Leftist refer to us as people of color, It bothers me Hispanics can be any complection, one of my friends is Chinese-Argentine! My point was I perfer the label Hispanic not minority or person of color that's all.
We should do something about the border. I would put the National Guard there. What I am upset about is Racist Trailer park trash llike Wet Willie Pirate wanting to deport Hispanics. The 12 million illegals if they commintted no crimes, should pay back taxes and go through procedures to legalize their status here.
Also the Conquistadorses didn't just conquer the americas they also drove the French out of Italy, stop the Turks in Hungary, conquer the German Protestants at the battle of Muhlberg and crush the Turkish feet at Lepanto.

Scout, take care.

Posted by Conquistador at March 29, 2006 06:46 PM

Conquistador, I have to disagree with you. I like being refered to as a person of color.
It justifies the shameless racist attitudes I endured when I was younger in CA. We hispanics stuck together and let the tolerent white friends in. Besides I do have a natural tan!
You remind me of my mother who uses the "blueblood" attitude on us.

Posted by bbtb at March 29, 2006 07:21 PM

Conquistadore,
Your as full ofshit as a Christmas goose.

You stupid Spainards basically just robbed the native Sout, Central and native Mexicans for the Catholic church.

Then we kicked your dumb asses out of Texasm the Southwest, California, the Phillipines and Cuba without breaking a damned sweat.

You stupid wetback fucks couldn't organize a circle at a Boy Scout Jamboree. You sure as hell can't run your own godamned countries because you treat 95% of your own citizens so poorly that they can't wait to get the fuck out of your corrupt countries to come to the US to work for 2.50 and hour to scrub toliets and wipe babies asses. You can forget about kicking anyone's ass over here in the US.

Furthermore, if your goddamned Spain is so fucking great, why don't you drag your sorry ass back over there and get a job picking fucking olives or fucking goats or whatever passes for an economy in your has-been country of origin.

Posted by WyldPirate at March 29, 2006 07:34 PM

BBTB,
It's an offensive term to me. We are people of many colors. Us Hispaics in South Florida find that term offensive and don't like it. But me and you can agree to disagree. Hey, you should leave Cali and come here. We're respected in Florida because back in the day we put the Trailer park White trash racists like wet Willie phony Pirate in their palce. They don't dare insult us here.

Posted by Conquistador at March 29, 2006 07:35 PM
[Editor: ignore=on]

Cnqstdr, s y knw, th Spnsh rld th wvs drng th 16th cntry. wld lk t knw wht th ttmn’s wr thnkng whn thy trd t tk n th Spnsh flt t Lpnt. Crp, vryn f ths Spnsh slrs wr t thr pk n trms f xprnc, knwldg nd tghnss. Whl th Trk’s wr nt wk, thy wr mst crtnly nt n th sm lvl s th Spnsh wth thr xcllnt shps nd lng dstnc slng sklls.

hp tht y cntn t prtcpt n ths st. Thy ll pt p wth m, t lst mst f th tm, nd knw th st dmn trs t mntn flvr f dmcrcy lngsd sm rgrs thnkng.

Whl cn’t spk fr Prt, m sspct tht h wsn’t thnkng bt th mny wmn nd chldrn tht crss th S brdr tryng t hv bttr lf. hp hs pnt ws t cntrl th brdrs nd hv dcmnttn f flks crssng vr.

n shrt stry tht hppnd fw yrs g. frnd nd , (Hspnc, Mxcn/mrcn) stppd t th lcl 7/11 t grb cl. W mt nc ldy tht mmdtly bgn t spk Spnsh. lthgh cn’t rmmbr nw wht sh sd, d rmmbr tht th wrds flwd frm hr jst s f sh ws sngng btfl sng. My frnd ntcd ths s wll: sh sd tht hr dlct ws ‘Cstln.’ ’ll bt y knw xctly wht ’m tlkng bt!

Thnks nd s y,

[Editor: ignore=off]

Posted by scout at March 29, 2006 07:47 PM

Trailer Park Trash pirate,

I was born here and my Grandfather fougt in WW2 to defeat rascists like you. As for you comments on history that was long ago when you guys won. I don't want a civil war but if Racist like get in power and try to come after us we would easily take part of this country. Those 95% that would come here from Latin America would, to help us out and take your land Klansman. explain how you'll win? The Russians and Chinese armies would join the Latin armies to crush you guys. I have more of a right to be here than you and your ancestors killled more Indians than mine. We intermmarried them and accepted them as brothers. I hope my scenario never happens but you'd lose. I mean most white kid nowadays are Gay or metrosexual we'd eat them for lunch! why don't you go and try taking on the Mexican and MS-13 gangs up there in N.C. They would cut your balls off and hang you from a Lamp post. Hey go back to whatever country you came from. Your so ignorant that you don't even know your own origin. You probably come from from an illiterate family where your Mom and Dad are Brother and Sister or Father and Daughter!
how many teeth your missing Cracker!

Posted by Conquistador at March 29, 2006 07:52 PM

Scout,
Please disregard what my back and forth with the racist redneck. I'm just letting him know that're consequences to his thinking. My girlfriend is French Canadian so I'm not racist.
We might have some political disagreements but hey that's the beauty of this county!

Posted by at March 29, 2006 07:59 PM

Scout,
Yes absolutely, Castillian is theSspanish from Spain. My grandmother was Castillian. It's cool to see you have an appppreciation of culture. I love it when my woman talks Quebecois to me. Funny thing, she perfers me to talk Spanish to her than English. She says that it's easier to understand. that what I love about this country the Multiculturalism. now if we can only deport the ignorant Racists like Trailer Pirate!

Posted by Conquistador at March 29, 2006 08:12 PM

Conquistador, Relocated to AZ now. Mom's from Guatemala, her dad was a colonel and a military attache to Washington in the 40's and 50's, so she is always on this "blueblood" line. She sure looks more indian than mestizo.

Posted by bbtb at March 29, 2006 10:40 PM

Scout: In 1588 King Phillip II sent the Spanish Armada to invade England. Elizabeth I had been helping the Dutch kick Spain's ass in the Protestant uprisings, and after 22 years of anal irritation, Phil got pissed off.

So the Nancy Boys in their smaller and faster ships, with the help of a storm, destroyed most of the fleet, setting up Brittania to rule the waves from there on in.

Rewriting history again?

Posted by TIKI AL at March 30, 2006 04:57 AM

To TIKI AL,
You are definately rewritting history. The Sppanish Armada at the end of the day suffered damage but was still intact. The English ran out of ammunition, then a storm came preventing the fleet to link uop with the Army of Flanders.
The Dutch were getting their asses kicked by the Spaniards not the other way around. Under the command of Alessandro Farnese the Italian Duke of Parma, the Spanish had pushed the Dutch to verge of Defeat. The reason the Spanish couldn't put way the Dutch is because Spain also was helping the French Catholics fight the Hugonauts and the Austro-Hungarian Hapsburgs against the Turks. Britain duidn't rule the waves after the Armada fiasco. The Spnaish Hapsburgs rebuilt the Spanish fleet using smaller ships called Zigarutas and actually defated the British is several naval engagements. In fact the Spanish were gaining the upper hand against the English, that in 1604 King James asked for a peace treaty.
England didn't become the dominant power until the French and Indian wars, also called the 7 years war in Europe. Actually when Spanish power collapsed in the 1640's it was Bourbon France that became the dominat power. Read your history and not Racist propaganda!

Posted by Conquistador at March 30, 2006 09:07 AM

BBTB,
I'm pretty sure you definately have Azteca blood in you. But that's the beauty of our culture, we are many peoples united by Language and culture.
I was just making the point that we come in many colors. Anyway it was good to coorespond with you.
Que dios te bendiga hermano!

Posted by Conquistador at March 30, 2006 09:14 AM

BBTB,
i meant Mayan blood sorry about that. Hey are going to see Apocalypto when it comes out?
Look pretty intersting and it's in the Mayan language. They always have fascinated me. How they just abandoned those great cities. Movie should be interestingI

Posted by Conquistador at March 30, 2006 09:18 AM

Hey are going to see Apocalypto when it comes out?

Conquistador, I'm not familiar with it.
Also, TIKI and I must have read the same history books, that is how I was taught in college. I remember the Spanish Fleet being pretty impotent after that invasion fiasco.

Posted by bbtb at March 30, 2006 09:45 AM

BBTB,

The Colleges in this country have a anti Hispanic bias when teaching history. Spain was far from Impotent, they rebuilt their fleet with smaller ships and Defeated the English and Dutch in many naval engagement, such as one in 1601 off the coast of Brittany. Spanish power didn't collapse until the 1640's due the the 30 Years war. A good Military History book about all wars is the Harper Encyclopedia of Military History.
That and other sources is where I get my facts.

Here's the link to Apocalypto:

http://apocalypto.movies.go.com/

Very interesting.

Take care.

Posted by Conquistador at March 30, 2006 10:03 AM

Looks interesting.

Posted by bbtb at March 30, 2006 10:41 AM

bb: Have I got this right? You went to a bogus college, and Encarta is racist crap?

Posting in the White House basement can lead to arthritus and radon poisoning. Look it up.

Posted by TIKI AL at March 30, 2006 03:27 PM
Post a comment
HTML Tags:
<b>Bold</b> = Bold
<i>Italics</i> = Italics
<a href="http://www.url.com/">Linked text</a> = Linked text

Note: comments from signed in commenters will show up right away. If you are not signed in, your comment will not appear until it has been approved.




Remember me?

(You may use HTML tags for style)

In order to post a comment, you must answer the following question.